KDLT Home KDLT on Facebook KDLT on Twitter Get the KDLT iPhone App Get the KDLT Android App

SD Supreme Court Asked To Strike Down Permit

Bookmark and Share

The South Dakota Supreme Court is being asked to throw out a state permit.

The air quality permit was issued for the Hyperion Oil Refinery, one of the largest industrial projects ever-proposed in South Dakota.

The granting of the permit created an uproar for many citizens and groups in the area of Elk Point.  They said the State Board of Minerals and Environment needed to take a closer look at the impact of the plant.

Wednesday morning at University of Sioux Falls, the South Dakota Supreme Court heard all sides.

Attorneys representing the citizens and groups against the plant said that the Environmental Impact Statement was needed before the permit was given. And it was needed to further review the impacts of the plant in all aspects- not just air pollution.

They also said the permit may have expired even after the company requested and was granted extensions.

Attorneys representing Hyperion and the DENR did not agree and said the EIS isn’t required for such a facility. They also said the permit never expired.

Gabrielle Sigal one attorney representing three groups against Hyperion's mutli-billion dollar facility said an Environmental Impact Study should have been required before giving the Prevention of Significant Deterioration Air Quality Permit.

They said the DENR 'abused discretion,' which means they did not follow standard procedures

 “They were not issuing an EIS because an EIS is much broader and encompasses many subject matters in which the board has no jurisdiction,” said Gabrielle Sigal.

Sigal went on and said they should have used other departments to conduct the study. It would have helped evaluate the broader impact.

Deputy Attorney Roxanne Giedd, who is representing then DENR, said the study is in fact out of their jurisdiction.

“It may provide lots of information for the other agencies, that is used to issue these other permits, but it doesn’t provide information for us,” said Roxanne Giedd.

Hyperion's attorney Frederick Addison agrees and said to get the permit the company legally did not need the study.    

"You are not required to perform an EIS for a federal clean air act permit,” said Frederick Addison.

The company has also asked to renew the permit to extend the start of construction. Which has the opposition questioning its validity.     

“PSD construction permits in South Dakota do not remain in affect pending appeal under the South Dakota permitting scheme,” said Robert Graham.

Robert Graham also an attorney for those who oppose Hyperion said it only stays in effect if there is continuing work on the site.

He said that's not the case on the land Hyperion plans to build on.

Addison said just because they aren't building doesn’t mean they aren't doing anything.

"We're extending and amending so we can have more time to build the facility. Is that continuing activity? It certainly is,” Addison said.

The final argument was in regards to whether or not the company had significant justification to renew the permit. The opposition said no, because the company used the recession as one of their reasoning’s. When they said the oil business is booming.

Hyperion’s attorney said it is difficult to keep moving forward when new requirements are given. He said they also feel its unwise to move forward if they don’t know all of their requirements.
Wednesday’s case came just days after Hyperion let options on the land they planned to build the refinery on expire. But company officials said they still plan on moving forward.

The court's ruling will be issued in a few months. 
< Prev Story Back To Top Next Story >

Rapid City Police Search For Missing Inmate

Department of Corrections staff members and local law enforcement are ...

Woman Dies In Rock Climbing Incident In SD

 Authorities say a 39-year-old woman has died as a result of injuries ...

IA Teen Dead After Climbing Onto Moving Train

Des Moines police say a teenager died while trying to climb onto a ...

West Des Moines Police Find Body, Burning Vehicle  Apr. 20

SD Birth Rate Rising After Recession Slump  Apr. 20

Governor's Mansion Hosts Easter Egg Hunt  Apr. 20

Dozens ‘Party For The Planet’  Apr. 19

SD Native Rises Above Tragic Accident  story with video  Apr. 19

Thousands Hunting For Easter Eggs  Apr. 19

Sioux Falls Storm Helps Kids In Need  story with video  Apr. 19

Sioux Falls Storm Helps Kids In Need  story with video  Apr. 19

Sioux City Riverboat Casino Prepares To Close  Apr. 19

After Wait, Ranchers Find Relief From USDA  Apr. 19

Man Approached Small Children In Mitchell  Apr. 19

Branstad Pushing Priorities On Lawmakers  Apr. 19

SD Lottery Offers Losing Tickets 2nd Chance  Apr. 19

CAMP Teams To Showcase Projects Saturday  Apr. 19

Separate Trials Ordered For Robbery Suspects  Apr. 19

IA Children's Museum Project Awarded Grant  Apr. 19

IA Gets Nearly $72M In Yearly Tobacco Payment  Apr. 19

Railroad Group Says $1 Million Pledged Locally  Apr. 19

Belle Fourche Clinic Offers Free Drug Tests  Apr. 19

Vikings To Add Another $1.2M To Stadium  Apr. 19

KDLT News Archive

SD Native Rises Above Tragic Accident  story with video

An Aberdeen native has been through what most will ...

Man Approached Small Children In Mitchell

Police are looking for a man who has approached ...

Thousands Hunting For Easter Eggs

The Easter Bunny made an early trip to drop off eggs at McKennan ...

Sioux City Riverboat Casino Prepares To Close  Apr. 19

SD Lottery Offers Losing Tickets 2nd Chance  Apr. 19

Sioux Falls Storm Helps Kids In Need  story with video  Apr. 19

After Wait, Ranchers Find Relief From USDA  Apr. 19

Sioux Falls Storm Helps Kids In Need  story with video  Apr. 19

KDLT News Archive

Storm Stomp Wyoming  story with video

SIOUX FALLS, S. D. --  The Sioux Falls Storm defeated the Wyoming Cavalry 64-29 Saturday night, ...

FORCED OUT: Fort Wayne Sweeps Sioux Falls  story with video

FORT WAYNE, IN --  The best Sioux Falls Skyforce season in ...

Red Raiders Roll Past Briar Cliff  story with video

ORANGE CITY, IA  --  The 20th-ranked Northwestern Red Raiders had little ...

Skyforce Need Complete Effort To Win In Fort Wayne  story with video  Apr. 19

Pitching Propels Jacks To Sweep At Fort Wayne  story with video  Apr. 19

Coyotes Drop Series Finale With IUPUI  story with video  Apr. 19

Coo Sweep Peacocks On Senior Day  story with video  Apr. 19

NSIC-Leading Mankato Slips Past Augie  story with video  Apr. 19

KDLT Sports Stories
Back To Top