KDLT Home KDLT on Facebook KDLT on Twitter Get the KDLT iPhone App Get the KDLT Android App

Death Penalty Still Possible For McVay



Bookmark and Share

The death penalty is still on the table after a motions hearing for James McVay has come to a close.

 

McVay’s lawyers argued that there is unequal funding between the State’s Attorney’s Office and the Public Defender’s Office on Thursday, in an attempt to eliminate the death penalty as a possible sentence.

 

James McVay is still facing a sentence of life in prison, or the death penalty.

 

McVay pleaded guilty but mentally ill to first degree murder in 2011. McVay walked away from the minimum security unit at the South Dakota State Penitentiary, before breaking into 75-year-old Maybelle Schein’s home, stabbing her in the neck, and stealing her car. McVay was eventually caught by police in Madison, WI.

 

During the second half of a two-day motions hearing on Thursday, McVay’s lawyers attempted to rule out the death penalty as a possible sentencing option, on the basis of unequal funding between the prosecution and defense.

 

McVay’s lawyers argued that they do not have the same funding or resources as the State’s Attorney’s Office.

 

Judge Peter Lieberman denied that motion, stating “the state will always have more resources available to them, such as law enforcement on both the local and state levels."

 

He went on saying “I have not seen anything lacking for the defense in this case whatsoever. The defense has not been anything but complete. If there is anything the defense has suffered from, it is over enthusiasm.”

 

Both parties presented statistics on budget amounts and expenditures, before Judge Lieberman concluded that there is no legal evidence supporting an issue of unequal  funding.

 

Minnehaha County State’s Attorney Aaron McGowan argued that “even if there was an issue of unequal funding, it would be no basis for the court to preclude the death penalty as a sentence.”

 

It was also determined on Wednesday that McVay’s TV interview will be used as evidence during his sentencing hearing.

 

McVay’s sentencing hearing is scheduled to begin in March.



< Prev Story Back To Top Next Story >
     

Dozens ‘Party For The Planet’

The Sioux Empire is celebrating Earth Day a couple days early, by taking a ...

SD Native Rises Above Tragic Accident  story with video

An Aberdeen native has been through what most will never experience in a ...

Thousands Hunting For Easter Eggs

The Easter Bunny made an early trip to drop off eggs at McKennan Park in Sioux ...

Sioux Falls Storm Helps Kids In Need  story with video  Apr. 19

Sioux Falls Storm Helps Kids In Need  story with video  Apr. 19

Sioux City Riverboat Casino Prepares To Close  Apr. 19

After Wait, Ranchers Find Relief From USDA  Apr. 19

Man Approached Small Children In Mitchell  Apr. 19

Branstad Pushing Priorities On Lawmakers  Apr. 19

SD Lottery Offers Losing Tickets 2nd Chance  Apr. 19

CAMP Teams To Showcase Projects Saturday  Apr. 19

Separate Trials Ordered For Robbery Suspects  Apr. 19

IA Children's Museum Project Awarded Grant  Apr. 19

IA Gets Nearly $72M In Yearly Tobacco Payment  Apr. 19

Railroad Group Says $1 Million Pledged Locally  Apr. 19

Belle Fourche Clinic Offers Free Drug Tests  Apr. 19

Vikings To Add Another $1.2M To Stadium  Apr. 19

Eric Church Nearly Sold Out  story with video  Apr. 18

Police Recover Weapon In Homicide Case  story with video  Apr. 18

Vigil Held In Opposition To Death Penalty  story with video  Apr. 18

KDLT News Archive
     

SD Native Rises Above Tragic Accident  story with video

An Aberdeen native has been through what most will ...

Man Approached Small Children In Mitchell

Police are looking for a man who has approached ...

Thousands Hunting For Easter Eggs

The Easter Bunny made an early trip to drop off eggs at McKennan ...

Sioux City Riverboat Casino Prepares To Close  Apr. 19

SD Lottery Offers Losing Tickets 2nd Chance  Apr. 19

Sioux Falls Storm Helps Kids In Need  story with video  Apr. 19

After Wait, Ranchers Find Relief From USDA  Apr. 19

Sioux Falls Storm Helps Kids In Need  story with video  Apr. 19

KDLT News Archive
     

Storm Stomp Wyoming  story with video

SIOUX FALLS, S. D. --  The Sioux Falls Storm defeated the Wyoming Cavalry 64-29 Saturday night, ...

FORCED OUT: Fort Wayne Sweeps Sioux Falls  story with video

FORT WAYNE, IN --  The best Sioux Falls Skyforce season in ...

Red Raiders Roll Past Briar Cliff  story with video

ORANGE CITY, IA  --  The 20th-ranked Northwestern Red Raiders had little ...

Skyforce Need Complete Effort To Win In Fort Wayne  story with video  Apr. 19

Pitching Propels Jacks To Sweep At Fort Wayne  story with video  Apr. 19

Coyotes Drop Series Finale With IUPUI  story with video  Apr. 19

Coo Sweep Peacocks On Senior Day  story with video  Apr. 19

NSIC-Leading Mankato Slips Past Augie  story with video  Apr. 19

KDLT Sports Stories
     
Back To Top